Here are the key points about PriorityQueue
and LinkedList
in Java:
Purpose & Underlying Structure:
- PriorityQueue: Primarily designed to keep elements in a priority-based sequence. It’s backed by an array-based binary heap.
- LinkedList: A general-purpose list implementation based on a doubly-linked list data structure.
Ordering:
- PriorityQueue: Elements are ordered based on their natural ordering (if they implement Comparable) or by a provided
Comparator
. They are not ordered by their insertion order. - LinkedList: Maintains the order of insertion. The list’s iteration order is the same as the insertion order.
Performance:
- PriorityQueue: Provides O(log n) time for insertion and O(1) time for retrieval of the highest-priority element, but O(n) for removal of an arbitrary element.
- LinkedList: Offers constant time (O(1)) for adding or removing at the beginning or end but linear time (O(n)) for operations at arbitrary positions.
Null Elements:
- PriorityQueue: Doesn’t support null elements.
- LinkedList: Allows null elements.
Usage Scenarios:
- PriorityQueue: Best when you need to frequently access the highest (or lowest) priority element.
- LinkedList: Suited for situations where list functionalities and deque operations are needed, and there are frequent insertions and deletions at the beginning or end.
Interfaces:
- PriorityQueue: Implements the
Queue
interface. - LinkedList: Implements both the
List
andDeque
(double-ended queue) interfaces, making it more versatile.
Iterators:
- PriorityQueue: The iterator provided does not guarantee any specific order.
- LinkedList: The iterator follows the sequence in which elements were inserted (or added).
Concurrency:
- Both are not thread-safe by default. External synchronization is needed if accessed concurrently by multiple threads.
Memory Overhead:
- PriorityQueue: Due to its array-based nature, it typically has less overhead than a linked list.
- LinkedList: Has more memory overhead because each entry needs two additional references (next and previous) for navigation.
Difference Between PriorityQueue and LinkedList in Java
Criteria | PriorityQueue | LinkedList |
---|---|---|
Underlying Data Structure | Heap (binary heap) | Doubly-linked list |
Ordering of Elements | Elements are ordered according to their natural ordering or by a provided comparator | Elements are stored in the order they were inserted |
Main Use-case | Implementing a priority queue where elements are retrieved by priority | General-purpose list where elements are added or removed frequently from the front or back |
Head Element | The least element with respect to the defined order | The first element that was inserted |
Performance | Insertion: O(log n), Removal: O(log n), Peek: O(1) | Insertion at end/start: O(1), Insertion at middle: O(n), Removal: O(1) for start/end and O(n) for middle, Access: O(n) |
Null Elements | Does not allow null elements | Allows null elements |
Interfaces Implemented | Queue | List, Deque |
Duplicates | Allows duplicates | Allows duplicates |
Example: Difference Between PriorityQueue and LinkedList in Java
import java.util.LinkedList;
import java.util.PriorityQueue;
import java.util.Queue;
public class PriorityQueueVsLinkedListDemo {
public static void main(String[] args) {
// Create a LinkedList and add elements
Queue<String> linkedList = new LinkedList<>();
linkedList.add("Apple");
linkedList.add("Banana");
linkedList.add("Cherry");
System.out.println("LinkedList:");
while (!linkedList.isEmpty()) {
System.out.println(linkedList.poll());
}
// Create a PriorityQueue and add elements
Queue<String> priorityQueue = new PriorityQueue<>();
priorityQueue.add("Apple");
priorityQueue.add("Banana");
priorityQueue.add("Cherry");
System.out.println("\nPriorityQueue:");
while (!priorityQueue.isEmpty()) {
System.out.println(priorityQueue.poll());
}
}
}
Output:
LinkedList: Apple Banana Cherry PriorityQueue: Apple Banana Cherry
Explanation:
1. LinkedList: A LinkedList is a doubly-linked list implementation of the List and Deque interfaces. It provides insertion, deletion, and access operations in constant time for both ends. Elements are added in the order they are inserted and are retrieved in the same order using the poll() method.
2. PriorityQueue: A PriorityQueue is a queue based on the natural ordering of its elements or based on a comparator provided at queue construction. It doesn't guarantee any specific order of elements but ensures that the highest priority element is served by the poll() method. If natural ordering is used, like in this example, then the smallest element (according to their natural order) is served first.
3. In the provided example, both the LinkedList and PriorityQueue have the same entries added. Since the natural order of strings is lexicographical order and the strings "Apple", "Banana", and "Cherry" are added in that order, the output for both the LinkedList and PriorityQueue appears the same.
4. In scenarios where you just need a list or queue structure without any order priority, LinkedList is a suitable choice. However, if you need to process elements based on some priority, then PriorityQueue should be used.