Let’s first take a look at key points about HashTable and HashMap:
Synchronization:
- HashTable: Synchronized, which means it’s thread-safe and can be safely used in multi-threaded applications without explicit synchronization.
- HashMap: Not synchronized, making it faster but not thread-safe by default.
Null Keys and Values:
- HashTable: Doesn’t allow any null key or value.
- HashMap: Allows one null key and multiple null values.
Performance:
- HashTable: Generally slower due to synchronization.
- HashMap: Typically faster since it doesn’t have the overhead of synchronization.
Inheritance:
- HashTable: Directly extends the
Dictionary
class. - HashMap: Extends the
AbstractMap
class and implements theMap
interface.
Iterators:
- HashTable: Uses
Enumeration
to retrieve keys and values. - HashMap: Uses
Iterator
for the same purpose. The iterator in HashMap is fail-fast.
Legacy:
- HashTable: It’s a legacy class and is considered obsolete for new code. Part of Java since its first version.
- HashMap: Introduced later in Java 2. It’s part of the Java Collections Framework (JCF) and is generally recommended over
HashTable
for new implementations.
Load Factor:
- HashTable: The default load factor is 0.75, which is a measure of how full the hash table is allowed to get before its capacity is automatically increased.
- HashMap: Allows specifying the load factor during initialization.
Order:
- HashTable: Doesn’t guarantee that the order of the map will remain constant over time.
- HashMap: Similarly, doesn’t guarantee order, but related classes like LinkedHashMap do.
Choosing between HashTable
and HashMap
largely depends on the specific needs of the application, especially regarding thread safety and performance requirements. For modern applications, HashMap (or its thread-safe counterpart, ConcurrentHashMap
) is generally preferred over HashTable.
Difference Between HashTable and HashMap in Java
Criteria | HashTable | HashMap |
---|---|---|
Synchronization | Synchronized | Not synchronized |
Null Keys and Values | Doesn’t allow any null key or null value | Allows one null key and multiple null values |
Performance | Generally slower due to synchronization | Faster because it is not synchronized |
Iterating | Enumerator for iteration (though it also has Iterator) | Iterator for iteration |
Fail-fast | Enumerator is not fail-fast | Iterator is fail-fast |
Legacy | Yes, it’s a legacy class | No |
Use-case | When thread safety is a priority, but consider using ConcurrentHashMap for a more modern approach | When thread safety is not required, or it’s controlled externally |
Example: Difference Between HashTable and HashMap in Java
import java.util.HashMap;
import java.util.Hashtable;
import java.util.Map;
public class HashTableVsHashMapDemo {
public static void main(String[] args) {
// Create a HashMap and add some key-value pairs
Map<String, String> hashMap = new HashMap<>();
hashMap.put("three", "cherry");
hashMap.put("one", "banana");
hashMap.put("two", "apple");
hashMap.put("four", "date");
System.out.println("HashMap:");
hashMap.forEach((key, value) -> System.out.println(key + " -> " + value));
// Create a Hashtable and add some key-value pairs
Map<String, String> hashTable = new Hashtable<>();
hashTable.put("c", "elephant");
hashTable.put("a", "grape");
hashTable.put("b", "fox");
hashTable.put("d", "honeydew");
System.out.println("\nHashtable:");
hashTable.forEach((key, value) -> System.out.println(key + " -> " + value));
}
}
Output:
HashMap: three -> cherry one -> banana two -> apple four -> date Hashtable: a -> grape b -> fox c -> elephant d -> honeydew
Explanation:
1. HashMap: A HashMap is an implementation of the Map interface that stores key-value pairs. It allows null keys and null values. It does not guarantee any specific order of the keys or values.
2. Hashtable: Hashtable is the older version of the HashMap and is synchronized. This means that it is thread-safe and can be used with multiple threads, but it brings a performance cost associated with synchronization. Hashtable does not allow null keys or values.
3. In the given example, both the HashMap and Hashtable store and retrieve key-value pairs. The insertion order in HashMap is not preserved like the Hashtable.
4. The decision to use HashMap or Hashtable often hinges on the need for synchronization. If thread safety is a concern, and you're working in a multithreaded environment, Hashtable might be considered. However, for single-threaded applications or situations where thread safety is managed externally, HashMap is generally more efficient and more commonly used in modern Java applications.